Skip to content
Use cases7 min read

Proof of Delivery Photos That Hold Up in “Not Received” and Damage Claims

A proof of delivery photo holds up when it is captured live, dated by an independent authority and sealed, so the customer, the carrier and the seller can each check when it was taken and that nothing changed since.

By Cédric Driaux, Founder of tryVidimus

Illustration of a closed cardboard box, taped shut, with a shipping label

What a delivery dispute really costs

A proof of delivery photo is meant to close a delivery, not to open an argument. This article is part of our series on photo evidence use cases. It covers the two claims that come back most often: “I never received it” and “it arrived damaged, or empty”.

We will not put a figure on these disputes: the cost depends on what you ship and to whom. What they are made of is easier to describe, and the parcel is only one part of it.

  • The goods. The item is refunded or sent again, sometimes both.
  • The time. Support agents collect photos and statements from the customer, the seller and the carrier, and compare them by hand.
  • The relationship. A customer who is asked to prove their good faith remembers it, and so does a seller who is refunded against their will.
  • The decision itself. When nothing can be checked, the platform decides by guesswork, and one of the parties feels wronged.

Three parties are involved, and each holds its own photos. The seller says the item went into the box. The carrier says the box was handed over. The customer says it was not, or that it was crushed. Each of them may be sincere, and nobody can check any of the three statements.

The weak points of today's proof of delivery photos

Most delivery photos are taken in good faith and still fail when someone contests them. The reasons are always the same.

Weak pointWhat the other side replies
The photo comes from the phone's gallery or a shared folder.“This photo was taken another day, or at another address.”
The date is the one written by the phone or by the carrier's own system.“You control that date.”
The photo was sent through a messaging app.“This is a compressed copy, and nobody knows where it came from.”
The files sit on the servers of the party that benefits from them.“You could have replaced them.”
The picture shows a parcel, with no label and no surroundings.“This is not my parcel, and that is not my door.”

Messaging apps deserve a word, because many teams still collect delivery photos that way. What arrives is a copy that neither side can tie to a date. Our article on WhatsApp photos and screenshots as evidence goes through what such a copy can and cannot establish.

Sealed capture at the doorstep

tryVidimus is an API that your delivery or marketplace application calls. It does not replace the driver's app: it adds a capture step to it.

  1. Your application creates a capture link for the order. The order number travels with it as a reference, so the proof is found again from the order.
  2. The driver opens the link at the door. A capture page opens in the browser or inside your app, with your logo and wording, and nothing to install.
  3. The driver takes the photos live. The camera is the only source: there is no upload from the gallery.
  4. The proof is sealed. Each file gets a SHA-256 fingerprint, the proof receives a qualified electronic timestamp, and each photo carries a C2PA signature.
  5. Your application is told. A signed webhook announces that the proof is sealed, and the proof has a public verification page that the customer can open without an account.

The files go straight to storage, without passing through your servers. That closes the “you could have replaced them” objection: you never held the files. If you want to see how the calls fit together, read our guide on how to add tamper-proof photo capture to your app.

Framing still matters. Ask for a shot that shows the parcel with its label, and one that shows where it was left or handed over: the door, the reception desk, the pickup counter. A shot template can define that list, so that every driver takes the same photos.

Packing photos before shipping

The delivery photo answers “was it delivered?”. It says nothing about what was in the box. For empty-box and not-as-described claims, the useful proof is made earlier, at packing.

The journey is the same, with the seller or the warehouse operator holding the phone:

  • The item on its own, with any serial number or distinctive mark visible.
  • The item inside the open box, with its padding.
  • The closed and taped box, with the shipping label readable.

Take a second-hand jacket sold on a marketplace. The buyer writes that the box was empty on arrival. The seller answers that they packed the jacket themselves. With a packing proof sealed before the parcel left, the platform no longer weighs one word against another. It has photos dated by a third party, taken before the dispute existed.

Two proofs can also be linked. When the same application runs both captures, the delivery proof can point back to the packing proof, as a before and an after. tryVidimus does not compare the photos and does not judge the damage. The same pattern serves a handover and a return, as in our article on proving vehicle condition at pickup and return.

When a sealed proof of delivery is worth it

To be honest about it: sealing every parcel rarely makes sense. Each sealed proof has a price, shown on the pricing page. It is justified mainly when the parcel is valuable, or when a dispute over it would cost you much more than the proof.

  • High-value goods: electronics, watches, bicycles, camera equipment, luxury second-hand items.
  • Deliveries without a signature, where the photo is the only trace of the handover.
  • Product categories or routes where claims come back often.
  • Sales between individuals on a marketplace, where neither party has a reputation to rely on.

The use cases page shows the parcel journey next to the others: the item, then the packed and closed box.

Frequently asked questions

Is a photo enough as proof of delivery?

It depends on who has to be convinced and on the rules that apply to the shipment. An ordinary photo is easy to contest: its date comes from the phone and the file can be replaced. A photo captured live, dated by an independent authority and sealed is much harder to contest, but it still does not show who received the parcel.

Can a customer dispute a sealed delivery photo?

Yes. A customer can always contest what the photo shows, for example by saying that the door is not theirs or that the parcel disappeared afterwards. What becomes hard to contest is the date of the capture and the fact that the file has not changed since. The dispute then bears on the facts, not on the origin of the photo.

Does the driver need a separate app?

No. The capture page is a web page opened from a link, in the phone's browser or inside the delivery application you already use. It carries your logo, your colour and your wording. The driver takes the requested photos live and goes on with the round. There is nothing to install on the phone.

How does a packing photo help against an empty-box claim?

It shows what the seller photographed going into the box, before the parcel left and before any dispute existed. The photos are captured live, sealed and dated by a third party, so it becomes hard to claim they were taken afterwards. They do not prove what the buyer found on opening the box: the platform or the insurer weighs both sides.

Can the sandbox be used for real deliveries?

No. The sandbox is free and lets you build and test the whole journey, from the capture link to the verification page. Its timestamps are simulated and have no legal value, so a sandbox proof must not be presented in a real dispute. Qualified timestamps are issued in production only.

Try it in the sandbox

A proof of delivery photo is worth what a third party can check about it: when it was taken, and that nothing changed since. Capture at packing and at handover, live, and keep it for the parcels where a dispute would really cost you. You can build and test the whole journey for free in the sandbox, without a card.

Create an account

Official sources

Cédric Driaux · Founder of tryVidimus

Cédric Driaux is the founder of tryVidimus, published by Fyher. He has been a software developer for 23 years. He also builds ScanStay, a photo proof tool for short-term rental hosts.

Related articles